Off the wire
Roundup: U.S. stocks rally amid robust jobs data  • Spotlight: NATO decides to strengthen security in eastern, southern flank  • More Americans think U.S. justice system biased against blacks as worry about racial ties keep rising  • Feature: 3,200 naked people turn streets of Hull into sea of blue for Britain's art project  • Burundi peace talks to resume in Tanzania on July 12th  • Top PKK leader killed in northern Syria bomb attack  • SA's Public Protector investigates alleged "state capture" by Gupta family  • Britain's Labour leader to face leadership challenge in bid to end party strife  • Pakistani PM returns home after successful open heart surgery  • Iraqi security forces recapture key airbase in south of Mosul  
You are here:   Home

News Analysis: Despite no indictment, Clinton's email scandal might help Trump's campaign

Xinhua, July 10, 2016 Adjust font size:

Though U.S. presumptive Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton has escaped indictment over her email controversy, her Republican rival Donald Trump still might benefit from the email scandal, experts said.

On Tuesday, Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) chief James Comey recommended not charging Clinton for her use of a private email server while she was secretary of state from 2009-2013.

But Comey, who was grilled on Thursday by a Republican-led House oversight committee, did slam Clinton and her team for being "extremely careless" in handling classified information.

Though Clinton has been cleared of criminal charges which could force her out of the presidential race, Trump will continue to sew it into his narrative about "crooked Hillary," a name Trump uses to describe what he sees as a dishonest Washington insider who doesn't abide by the rules.

Trump has depicted Clinton as an elitist insider in what he calls a system rigged to benefit her.

"It can help him," Julian Zelizer, professor of history and public affairs at Princeton University, told Xinhua, referring to how the decision not to indict would impact Trump.

"The story will now continue, particularly because of Comey's tough comments about what she did. In addition, he (Trump) will claim, and already is claiming, that the decision not to move forward with the case was some kind of political deal," Zelizer said.

Indeed, Clinton has been embroiled in a scandal over whether she jeopardized U.S. national security by using a private email account and server for official business while she was Secretary of State, instead of using a State Department email account and a secure government-protected server.

"Trump will continue to use his crooked Hillary line because even though she was not indicted, the FBI director did say she and her staff were careless in how they handled classified information," said Darrell West, vice president of director of governance studies of the Brookings Institution.

"That gives Republicans some ammunition that it was not a complete vindication of Clinton. She will bask in headlines saying she has been cleared by the FBI while opponents will continue to say the episode reflects poorly on her personal judgment," West said.

Still, West said he doubts many minds will be changed by the issue, because 85 percent to 90 percent of Americans already have made up their minds about the election.

"The people who think she was dishonest will continue to think that, while those who support her will still believe she is far preferable to Trump. In the end, the election is likely to turn more on big issues of the economy, immigration, and terrorism than this email scandal," West said.

Meanwhile, critics noted what they call a cozy relationship between Clinton and a number of individuals in the Justice Department, which oversees the FBI.

U.S. Attorney General Loretta Lynch, who heads the Justice Department, was appointed by Hillary's husband and former President Bill Clinton in 1999 to be the U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of New York.

Moreover, Justice Department employees have contributed nearly 75,000 U.S. dollars to Clinton's presidential campaign, U.S. media reported. Endit